Joseph Patrick Gamerl of the Fairfax County PoliceAccused of Soliciting Minors for Sex - Former Police Captain Accused of Soliciting Minors for Sex The former captain was arrested in June on charges he inappropriately touched a 10-year-old gir...
Fairfax County Police Watch: John Geer shooting: Fairfax prosecutor resumes probe in police killing of John Geer in 2013 By Tom Jackman The Fairfax County prosecutor is resuming his...
Fairfax County Police Watch: Senate committee kills police asset forfeiture bil...: By Patrick Wilson The Virginian-Pilot RICHMOND A Senate committee on Tuesday killed a bill that would prevent police from se...
Fairfax County Police Watch: Fairfax Co. police release more details in woman’s...: Fairfax Co. police release more details in woman’s stun gun death By Sarah Beth Hensley WASHINGTON — Police have released new detail...
FOIA Request On Effectiveness Of License Plate Readers Greeted With A Blank Stare By Virginia Police Department
from the I'm-not-familiar-with-the-sort-of-thing-you're-asking-for dept
Law enforcement agencies are generally pretty happy with their automatic license plate readers. It allows them to harvest millions of plate/location records without having to exit their vehicles, much less slow them down. It also allows them to spring from their cruisers with guns out and force non-car thieves into submissive positions while they perform the sort of due diligence that should have been completed long before the cops/guns exited their respective holders.
What they don't seem to like is anyone asking questions about the massive databases they're compiling or whether they've bothered to institute any minimization/privacy policies. When questioned, they usually talk about what a great tool it is for crime-fighting, even if said tool contains millions of useless photos entirely unrelated to criminal activity. Some even claim that every single photo in the database is integral to ongoing investigations and therefore cannot be subjected to minimization procedures, much less the pesky FOIA requests of surveilled citizens.
And sometimes, these agencies are so sure they like the tech that they can't even be bothered to determine whether it's actually doing anything to assist in the business of law enforcement. Stephen Gutowski at the Capitol City Project recently asked the Fairfax County, VA police about the effectiveness of its license plate photo database and got this 'FILE NOT FOUND' statement in response.
This letter is in response to your FOIA request in which you requested the number of ALPR records Fairfax County currently has on file. This number is constantly fluctuating, but as of 05/20/2014 at 1003 hours there were 2,731,429 reads in the system.
You further requested any available metric the county uses to determine the system's effectiveness. It was found that the Fairfax County Police Department does not possess any such responsive materials based on the information you requested.
The assumption here is that the system works. The Fairfax County PD occasionally posts arrests linked to ALPR database hits and… well, beyond that, the PD draws a blank. Presumably a handful of arrests justifies a multi-million image-and-location photo database. But this lack of self-assessment shouldn't be acceptable, not for an agency that has abused its technology in the past.
It came to light late last year that the Fairfax PD trolled political rallies to grab more plate data, racking up nearly 70,000 photos in five days. This abuse prompted a local lawmaker to push legislation aimed at severely limiting, if not completely eradicating, ALPR readers in his district. Not a bad idea, as far it goes.
Virginia law enforcement agencies aren't going to be happy with this move and they'll be able to mobilize a pretty powerful opposition. But these are the same entities that tried to bury info on plate readers back in 2009, simply because they felt the public might try to get the system shut down if they knew what was going on. But the lack of controls or any gauge of the system's effectiveness shouldn't be allowed to escape unnoticed, because the failure to monitor error rates and hits can result in catastrophic consequences for citizens whose plates trigger false hits -- something this system does at twice the rate of recoveries.
The license plate readers demonstrated a high error rate. Four ALPR vehicles used in Fairfax County over the course of five nights in February 2009 scanned 69,281 vehicles. The camera database produced twelve bogus hits and recovered four stolen vehicles, for a recovery rate of 0.6 percent and an error rate of 1.7 percent.
The technology can be used responsibly, but law enforcement agencies with tough minimization policies are almost nonexistent. And as we've seen twice in the last month alone, officers relying on faulty data aren't making an effort to verify database hits before attempting to effect arrests. Someone's going to be hurt or killed because of bad data, and hardly anyone in law enforcement seems to be concerned. If they did, strict policies on verification and disposal of non-hit data would be the rule, rather than the exception.
BY RON GALLAGHER
RALEIGH --- One police officer's gun went off and another officer was wounded in the leg early Thursday as Raleigh police answered a call about a man who had been waving a handgun at an apartment complex in North Raleigh.
Officer K.J. Barefoot, 31, was taken to WakeMed Hospital in Raleigh for treatment of the leg wound and later released.
Police arrested Joshua Daniel Timberlake, 28, on a domestic-abuse charge related to the incident. The department is still investigating how Barefoot was shot when police arrived at Timberlake's home in the Meridian at Wakefield apartment complex early Thursday morning.
During the incident, Sgt. J.D. Malzahn's service sidearm fired, police spokesman Jim Sughrue said. Police had not determined whether that was the only shot and whether it was Malzahn's round that struck Barefoot, he said. No one else has been charged in the shooting.
Malzahn has worked for the department since November 2009 and Barefoot joined in June 2012.
The Fairfax County cops are painting a car with distracting sentences and parking it near a busy road to stop drivers from being distracted.
This leads us to the question…..does it get….could it possibly get..…more white trashy than this? People, we have got to elect someone to the Board of Supervisors who will take charge the morons at the police department, I mean, my God, what’s next? Mandatory incest? Regulation flower planters in old tires on our front lawns?
It’s terrible to pick on the mouth breathers I know, and yes, understandably most cops on the Fairfax County police force probably have an abandoned car on cinderblocks in their drive way in Loudon County so printed cars make sense to them and yes, were in Dixie, but Good Lord, can we at least try to pretend were not? I mean….printed cars?
I’m going to write this next sentence slowly so as not to confuse the cops: A car covered in anti-drinking- and-driving sentences will not decrease the vast number of idiots who drive around drunk. They’re too drunk to read the notes side of the car and attention deficit drivers are too busy to read it.
The cops say that it’s okay for this idiocy to happen because the printing cost is being covered by Transurban, the people who operate the 495 Express Lanes. You want stop crime? Arrest those shameless money hungry pricks.
Start there and work your way up to finding the missing files in the John Geer shooting case then you’ll have the credibility to tell other people about obeying law. We would rather live with drunk and distracted driver than with a police force that guns down unarmed citizens.
Fairfax County Police Watch: Fairfax County Police kill another unarmed man.: According to the latest reports, the homeless man gunned down the shoot-happy Fairfax County police was unarmed. It appears that the...